| Name | Category | City | Message | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| PRIYANSHU KAUSHAL | Student | DELHI | Please add the cma in defination of accountant. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:48 PM |
| Kartheek Reddy Varra | Member | Andhra Pradesh | We need Tax audit opportunity to further strengthen our tax audit system | 22 Feb 2025, 01:48 PM |
| Mahima gupta | Student | Kolkata/west bengal | Cost accountants should be include in the definition of accoutants. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:48 PM |
| Ashish Kumar Choudhary | Student | kolkata | Cma's must be included to reduce monopoly of ca profession as cma's also possesses vast knowledge of accounting and taxation.If the syllabus is same then why the power isn't same | 22 Feb 2025, 01:47 PM |
| Santu jana | Student | Kolkata | 22 Feb 2025, 01:47 PM | |
| SUDHAKAR KUMAR | Student | pratapgarh | Write to Equality | 22 Feb 2025, 01:47 PM |
| Suryansh gaur | Student | Mathura | Its high time to consider a CMA in the defination o accountants. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:46 PM |
| Riya M | Kerala | 22 Feb 2025, 01:45 PM | ||
| Kumar | Student | Ap | Tax audit is not exclusive domain of CAs only, CMA have same cuiculum & standards in taxation. To achieve 2047 viksith bharath goals govt should diversify the services for the smoothen the taxation process within due time without any frauds. |
22 Feb 2025, 01:45 PM |
| Aditi Singh | Student | Kolkata | Inclusion of CMA in definition of accountant in new income tax act 2025 | 22 Feb 2025, 01:45 PM |
| AMIT BALDWA | Member | MAHARASHTRA | 22 Feb 2025, 01:45 PM | |
| Sangita Dalai | Student | Jamshedpur | Yes, as a CMA student,I also agree with this petition. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:45 PM |
| Ashish Kumar Jha | Student | New Delhi | ##Include CMA as in Accountant definition ## Justice For CMA Students ##Equality | 22 Feb 2025, 01:44 PM |
| Sachin Kumar | Student | Ranchi | It's a necessary, you all know about this,CMAs Can do any things as well as CA. Make it | 22 Feb 2025, 01:44 PM |
| NAZIR AHMED | KOLKATA | 22 Feb 2025, 01:44 PM | ||
| Sunil | Member | Bihar | 22 Feb 2025, 01:43 PM | |
| VISWA | Others | CHENNAI | I support this Memorandum #TaxAudit For CMA's #Inclusion of CMA's in Accountant definition | 22 Feb 2025, 01:43 PM |
| Chandra Sekhar Mohta | Student | West Bengal | I'm Pursuing for Intermediate Group & urging to add/recognize CMA's & CS's in the "Accountants" definition under Section 288(2). | 22 Feb 2025, 01:43 PM |
| Swayam Dhadange | Bhiwandi | 22 Feb 2025, 01:43 PM | ||
| Dharmendra Wadhwa | Others | Bengaluru | 22 Feb 2025, 01:43 PM | |
| Rajesh | Student | Tamilnadu | 22 Feb 2025, 01:42 PM | |
| Minto Kumar Sah | Others | West Bengal | My son passed CMA INTERMEDIATE | 22 Feb 2025, 01:42 PM |
| Vibha Gupta | Member | Bihar | I support the cause | 22 Feb 2025, 01:42 PM |
| SUPROTIM MANNA | Student | Howrah | 22 Feb 2025, 01:42 PM | |
| Vibha gupta | Member | Bihar | I support the cause | 22 Feb 2025, 01:42 PM |
| Arjun S Menon | Member | Thrissur | Since both the institutes have almost same curriculum in filed of taxation.It is essential to recognise CMA in definition of “Accountants” under section 515(3)(b) to have a healthy competition between institutes which will be a value addition to our country. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:41 PM |
| Yakshit Singh Rajpurohit | Student | Bhilai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:41 PM | |
| RAGHVENDRA DUBEY | Member | Gonda | 22 Feb 2025, 01:41 PM | |
| Bikash Ram | Student | Kolkata | Having the same knowledge of Direct Tax but still not getting the recognition, So my appeal to the honourable Finance Minister to include CMA as accountant in the new Direct tax bill. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:41 PM |
| Mohammed saif khan | Student | Korba / chhattisgarh | I agree with this petition and i support that cost accountants should be added in the income tax act | 22 Feb 2025, 01:41 PM |
| Shristy Shahi | Student | Bihar | I am qualified CMA and I really want tax audit in our hand. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM |
| Pooja Vasant Pobatti | Student | Mumbai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM | |
| Aditya Singh | Student | Faridabad | As a future Cost and Management Accountant I request that we should be included in the defination of ACCOUNTANT | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM |
| Sonali Suresh Patange | Student | Vangani | Now a days being CMA is hard as being CA and the syllabus is also same. We also have to study everything. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM |
| Pritam Chanda | Student | Kolkata | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM | |
| Vivek Patel | Student | Gaya | I support because it's needed | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM |
| Lakshit Mangla | Student | Jind | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM | |
| Rupa Singh | Student | West Bengal | 22 Feb 2025, 01:40 PM | |
| Mangipudy Aditya Tarun | Student | Hyderabad | Yeah it is a equal right for both ca and cma people , CMA should rise their voice. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM |
| Suraj Shaw | Student | kolkata | Its our right to explore new areas of our curriculum.... please provide us with this opportunity | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM |
| Lakshit Mangla | Student | Jind | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM | |
| Kamalakanta Mallik | Member | Odisha | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM | |
| Jay Bhanushali | Student | Mumbai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM | |
| Kunal Hotchandani | Student | Ulhasnagar | CMA should also get right for tax audit due to their speciality in taxation | 22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM |
| KANNAN | Others | CHENNAI | It has been observed that many *Chartered Accountants (CAs)*, especially those involved in teaching, often use both *CA* and *CMA* designations in their books or classes, particularly when covering subjects like *Direct Taxation* and *Indirect Taxation*. This practice suggests a recognition that both the *CA* and *CMA* curricula encompass similar topics in taxation, thereby acknowledging that *CMA professionals* possess a comparable depth of knowledge in taxation matters. This observation can serve as a strong counterpoint to the argument that *Tax Audit* is exclusively within the domain of *CAs*. The fact that *CA professionals* themselves teach and recognize the shared taxation syllabus, including topics covered by CMAs, indirectly affirms that CMAs are equally competent in areas of *taxation* and *tax-related audits*. Therefore, the claim that *Tax Audit* should be restricted solely to *CAs* overlooks the fact that *CMA professionals* are equally trained and proficient in handling complex tax matters, as evidenced by their comprehensive *taxation syllabus*. In light of this, it is essential to recognize and respect the role of both *CAs* and *CMAs* in the *taxation domain*, as both professions are equipped with the requisite skills and knowledge to provide quality services in this area. |
22 Feb 2025, 01:39 PM |
| Sayan Mandal | Howrah West Bengal | 22 Feb 2025, 01:38 PM | ||
| Rushikesh Phadtare | Pune | 22 Feb 2025, 01:38 PM | ||
| Akhilesh Kumar Bhuchar | Member | Ludhiana | From Govt's perspective, the inclusion will be an internal controle /check. Besides I fully support the reasons enumerated in the Memorandum. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:38 PM |
| Sumeet wadhwa | Student | Ulhasnagar | 22 Feb 2025, 01:38 PM | |
| CMA NISHIKANTA DIGAR | Member | BARIPADA,MAYURBHANJ, ODISHA | Cost accountant must be included as accountant as per definition of income tax bill 2025, since we have same curriculum in employment, course of study , and have experty at par. Further chartered accountants are allowed to GST audit which was domain of cost accountant in excise era. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:37 PM |
| govind | Mumbai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:37 PM | ||
| KALPANA | Others | CHENNAI | It has been observed that many *Chartered Accountants (CAs)*, especially those involved in teaching, often use both *CA* and *CMA* designations in their books or classes, particularly when covering subjects like *Direct Taxation* and *Indirect Taxation*. This practice suggests a recognition that both the *CA* and *CMA* curricula encompass similar topics in taxation, thereby acknowledging that *CMA professionals* possess a comparable depth of knowledge in taxation matters. This observation can serve as a strong counterpoint to the argument that *Tax Audit* is exclusively within the domain of *CAs*. The fact that *CA professionals* themselves teach and recognize the shared taxation syllabus, including topics covered by CMAs, indirectly affirms that CMAs are equally competent in areas of *taxation* and *tax-related audits*. Therefore, the claim that *Tax Audit* should be restricted solely to *CAs* overlooks the fact that *CMA professionals* are equally trained and proficient in handling complex tax matters, as evidenced by their comprehensive *taxation syllabus*. In light of this, it is essential to recognize and respect the role of both *CAs* and *CMAs* in the *taxation domain*, as both professions are equipped with the requisite skills and knowledge to provide quality services in this area. |
22 Feb 2025, 01:37 PM |
| MAJETY ACHUTH KUMAR | Hyderabad | 22 Feb 2025, 01:37 PM | ||
| Govind Bhat P | Member | Bangalore | Request to include CMA's in the definition of Accountant in the new Income Tax Act. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:37 PM |
| Niraj | Maharashtra | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | ||
| UMESH | KANNUR | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | ||
| SURESH PRUSTY | Dhenkanal | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | ||
| Sangram Das | Student | Kolkata | strongly support the inclusion of the Chartered Management Accountant (CMA) in the definition of an accountant in the new bill. CMAs possess specialized expertise in management accounting, financial strategy, and decision-making that are critical to the success of businesses and organizations. Recognizing CMAs as qualified accountants will ensure a more comprehensive and inclusive approach to professional standards, reflecting the broad range of skills and qualifications that contribute to financial stewardship and business growth. This inclusion will benefit the profession and help enhance the effectiveness of accounting practices in various sectors.Please End the unfair monopoly of CA,s. Monopoly is always harmful for the society. Must included CMA in Tax audit ambit because CMA is expert in Direct Taxation field. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM |
| 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | ||||
| Daipayan Ghosh | Kharagpur | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | ||
| Sankarshan Rathi | Student | Nashik | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM | |
| Sanu Bera | Student | West Bengal | I support this movement. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM |
| Amitava Dutta | Member | Kolkata | ITR 3,4,5 & 6 (all profession & business related ITR) manufacturing account considered with as the base for entire profitability derivation. Therefore the role of CMA can't be avoided for entire IT assessment. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:36 PM |
| Pruthvi Raj Choti | Student | Hyderabad | 22 Feb 2025, 01:35 PM | |
| Paresh Hati | Student | Bhubaneswar | 22 Feb 2025, 01:35 PM | |
| Pallavi Verma | Bahrain | 22 Feb 2025, 01:35 PM | ||
| Mohd Ayan | Student | Kanpur | INCLUDE CMA IN DEFINITION OF ACCOUNTANT | 22 Feb 2025, 01:35 PM |
| Atul kumar Atul | Student | Kolkata | 22 Feb 2025, 01:35 PM | |
| Sekhar SenGupta | Member | Kolkata/ West Bengal | CMAs are no meaner to CAs so why the difference? A respectable profession should get it's due treatment. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| shireen chirakkal | Member | Kozhikode | CMAs are eligible to be included in the definition of Accountant in the new proposed Income Tax Bill 2025 in terms of available members, expertise, knowledge and the academics. Please do justice to CMA | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| Ranjib sahoo | Student | Cuttack | ADD ACCOUNTANT | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| K p gupta | Member | Delhi | It's unfair to concentrate eligibility and opportunity with Members of one institute whereas other similarly placed professionals of other institutes are not utilised resulting in concentration at the cost of industry and users of services. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| Vivek Patel | Student | Gaya | I support the cause | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| Anjali Agarwal | Others | Jamshedpur | I am in favour of including cost accountants in the definition of accountant | 22 Feb 2025, 01:34 PM |
| Rohit Kumar | Student | Gurgaon | Yes I support | 22 Feb 2025, 01:33 PM |
| Neha Ansari | Others | Mumbai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:33 PM | |
| Vivek Singh | Kalyan | 22 Feb 2025, 01:32 PM | ||
| Nikhil Mogal | Student | Nashik, Maharashtra | Support to inclusion of CMA in New Income Tax Act -2025 | 22 Feb 2025, 01:32 PM |
| MUHAMMED ANAS E | Member | Malappuram/Kerala | 22 Feb 2025, 01:32 PM | |
| PITABAS SHA | Member | Odisha | A CMA should be comes under “Accountant”. So I support the cause. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:32 PM |
| Salauddin khan | Student | Mumbai | I just say, if chartered accountant termed as professional accountant and professionals include in definition of "accountant" accordingly cost and management accountant also termed as professional then why it is not considered accountant in the definition of "accountant" | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Srinivas G N S | Member | Hyderabad | I support inclusion of Cost Accountants in practice under the definition of Accountant U/s 515 (3)(b) of Income Tax Act | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Soumik Das | Student | Asansol | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM | |
| Tarun Vashisht | Student | Delhi | Cma deserve tax audit so add cost accountant in defination | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Soham Bose | Student | Kolkata | I support the cause | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Ritu Singh | Student | Kolkata | I am CMA Final student,we want tax audit power | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Annapoorani | Student | Madurai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM | |
| Ritesh Agrawal | Student | Parbhani | CMA should be added in the definition of accountant in new income tax act | 22 Feb 2025, 01:31 PM |
| Shivam Maurya | Student | Bhadohi Uttar Pradesh | Yes! I Support the Cause | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| ANDAPALLY MANOHARREDDY | Student | Hyderabad | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM | |
| Jay Meher | Others | Bhubaneswar | I support | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| Spandan aayush | Student | Patna | Company Secretaries (CS) and Cost and Management Accountants (CMA) will be allow because we also learned what a ça have learned to conduct tax audits. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| Shreya Devendra Thakur | Student | Mumbai | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM | |
| Ganta vasudev chandra | Student | Bhubaneswar | I agree to support the request to government for inclusion of cost accountants in the definition of accountant. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| Arvind | Student | Badalapur | Cma should get tax audit | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| Chandan sahu | Student | Bihar patna | I agree with this petition. As a CMA student,i think this should be done. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:30 PM |
| Pavan | Others | Telangana | Qualified cost and management accountant | 22 Feb 2025, 01:29 PM |
| Shakshi Gandhi | Student | Sainthia | 22 Feb 2025, 01:29 PM | |
| Abdul Mateen | Student | Delhi | We are eligible but didn't give us opportunity | 22 Feb 2025, 01:29 PM |
| Tanisha Sharma | Student | Bhadson | I think that CMA. Professionals have aqual knowledge which CA. Professionals have. CMA. Professionals are also capable for maintaining accounts and doing Tax audits, So CMA. Professionals are also to be included in the defination of accountant. | 22 Feb 2025, 01:29 PM |