| Name | Category | City | Message | Date |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Aswini | Member | Hyderabad | Practicing cma of 3yrs | 20 Feb 2025, 05:21 AM |
| Sandeep Pandit | Member | Mathura | HARE KRISHNA | 20 Feb 2025, 05:18 AM |
| Diksha | Student | Bangalore | Yes , if we are studying in so depth then why not we can practice also as a tax Auditor . It would be a honour for all CMA’s to perform TAX Audit and can count as a Accountant | 20 Feb 2025, 05:15 AM |
| Shaji Thomas | Student | Alappuzha | 20 Feb 2025, 05:07 AM | |
| MAHENDRA PADHAN | Member | SUBARNA PUR | CMA should be called as Accountant . | 20 Feb 2025, 04:58 AM |
| G pavan kumar reddy | Student | Hyderabad | As we also have same subjects like Advanced accounts , Taxation, GST and Financial reporting as same as CA except audit, So I strongly believe we as CMA should include in the definition of accountant, otherwise our efforts and sleepless nights and studies are waste being as a professional | 20 Feb 2025, 04:58 AM |
| Nayshar shah | Others | Ahmedabad | Please include CMA under the definition Accountant in income tax law for getting opportunities to conduct Audits | 20 Feb 2025, 04:57 AM |
| Padma Rao | Member | Mumbai/ Maharashtra | I am an accomplished Cost accountant and am a Consultant to the World Bank. I am of the opinion that Cost accountants have the skill and training to be considered Accountant under the new Income Tax law | 20 Feb 2025, 04:57 AM |
| Dashrath Singh | Member | South West Delhi | Another initiative of AICMAA by petitioning the Parliament for the inclusion of *Cost Accountants* in the Definition of " *Accountant* " as outlined in the Section 515(3)(b) under the proposed Income Tax Bill-2025. |
20 Feb 2025, 04:57 AM |
| Vijayalakshmi | Student | Puducherry | 20 Feb 2025, 04:42 AM | |
| Cynthia John | Student | Puducherry | 20 Feb 2025, 04:36 AM | |
| JAGADISH CHOUDHURY | Others | GUWAHATI::ASSAM | 20 Feb 2025, 04:35 AM | |
| Tarandeep Singh | Student | Amritsar | 20 Feb 2025, 04:23 AM | |
| CMA Priyank Vyas | Member | Vadodara | Request to GOI As we equivalent with CA in all the categories, Direct and Indirect Tax is also a common in both Institutes syllabus, both members are equally equipped with the both tax law then why exclusion in definition from Accountants. Kindly include our members also |
20 Feb 2025, 04:13 AM |
| Ashwinibhattad | Student | Nashik road, Nashik. | 20 Feb 2025, 04:06 AM | |
| Santosh Patra | Member | CUTTACK | PETITION TO THE PARLIAMENT FOR INCLUSION OF "COST ACCOUNTANT" IN THE DEFINITION OF "ACCOUNTANT" IN THE NEW INCOME TAX BILL-2025 |
20 Feb 2025, 04:00 AM |
| Ayush jaiswal | Student | West Bengal | CMA must be included in the definition of Accountant in the New Income Tax Bill 2025. This results will Provide a great opportunity to Upcoming CMA's Who want to do Practice. | 20 Feb 2025, 03:54 AM |
| SRINIVASARAO KURRA | Member | Hyderabad | Please include CMA under the definition Accountant in income tax law for getting opportunities to conduct Audits srinivasaraokurra | 20 Feb 2025, 03:02 AM |
| Ratikanta Patra | Member | Dhenkanal | The GOI should re consider the definition of Accountant and also consider the Cost Accountant as Accountant for tax audit. | 20 Feb 2025, 02:58 AM |
| Atish Kumar Mohanty | Member | Odisha | Include CMA in new Income Tax Act | 20 Feb 2025, 02:56 AM |
| Shamik Dutta | Student | West Bengal | I strongly believe that CMA should be included under the purview of Accountant. | 20 Feb 2025, 02:50 AM |
| Anand Kumar | Student | Patna | 20 Feb 2025, 02:49 AM | |
| Deep Shikha | Member | Kolkata | 20 Feb 2025, 02:47 AM | |
| Jaffer Hussain | Member | Mumbai | As the petition is for inclusion of CMA as a Accountant in Income Tax Act and I totally Support this petition. As all the profession CA/CS/CMA are equal in nature and and similar knowledge in field of taxation then why some professions given a extra benefit and some are excluded from it. | 20 Feb 2025, 02:44 AM |
| Snigdha | Member | Bhilai | 20 Feb 2025, 02:34 AM | |
| Jayant charan pahari | Member | Greater Noida | Must be include CMA as a difinition of Accountant in income tax act for better competitive Environment. | 20 Feb 2025, 02:32 AM |
| Siman sarkar | Delhi | Yes I agree | 20 Feb 2025, 02:31 AM | |
| Bidyadhar ojha | Member | Bhadrak | 20 Feb 2025, 02:26 AM | |
| Sri ram Meher | Student | BOUDH | Yes | 20 Feb 2025, 02:16 AM |
| CMA Hammad Abbas | Member | New Delhi | 20 Feb 2025, 02:16 AM | |
| CMA Santiram Chattopadhyay | Member | Mumbai Maharashtra | Yes I agree Fully to Include CMA in New Income Tax Act 2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 02:15 AM |
| Aswin v | Student | Kerala | 20 Feb 2025, 02:11 AM | |
| bikash behera | Student | Odisha | Cma should get tax audit because in cma syllabus more subjects in taxation and it is directly related with cost | 20 Feb 2025, 02:08 AM |
| Faisal Firdous | Student | Kolkata | CMA should be provided with tax Audit as Taxes protion are same in both | 20 Feb 2025, 02:03 AM |
| Prince Yadav | Student | Varanasi Uttar Pradesh | As the petition is for inclusion of CMA as a Accountant in Income Tax Act and I totally Support this petition. As all the profession CA/CS/CMA are equal in nature and and similar knowledge in field of taxation then why some professions given a extra benefit and some are excluded from it. |
20 Feb 2025, 01:55 AM |
| Alur Hemant | Hyderabad | COST AND MANAGEMENT ACCOUNTANT is capable of TAX AUDIT. | 20 Feb 2025, 01:55 AM | |
| Vishnu Budhavant | Student | Maharashtra | For broadening the area's and aspects of working environment | 20 Feb 2025, 01:51 AM |
| Karan Malik | Student | Aligarh/ Uttar Pradesh | inclusion of *Cost Accountants* in the Definition of " *Accountants* " as outlined in the Section 515(3)(b) under the proposed Income Tax | 20 Feb 2025, 01:42 AM |
| Ayushi Kesarwani | Student | Prayagraj , up | Cma's should be included in new tax bill . | 20 Feb 2025, 01:34 AM |
| Umang kumar | Patna | Must inclusion of CMA in definition of Accountant under new Income Tax code | 20 Feb 2025, 01:33 AM | |
| Sachin | Others | Delhi | 20 Feb 2025, 01:25 AM | |
| Vishal Sharma | Member | Dhanbad Jharkhand | As per section 129 of Companies Act 2013, financial statements shall give a true and fair view of the states of affairs of the company, but as per prevailing practice in India, there is a monopoly of a single institute over the signing of the same. In order to remove such practices and create a healthy competition, the word accountant must be ammendment by including our ICMAI Institute | 20 Feb 2025, 01:20 AM |
| Richa Lakhaiyar | Student | Jharkhand | 20 Feb 2025, 01:17 AM | |
| Suraj Keshri | Student | Ranchi | Bahut saare deshon me Management Accountants ko audit aur certification powers diye gaye hain, jaise: UK me CIMA professionals ko certification powers milti hain. USA me CMA aur CPA dono ko taxation aur audit me role diya gaya hai. Canada me CPA aur CMA merge ho chuke hain, jisme taxation aur audit ka role include hai. Agar globally CMA ko recognition mil raha hai, to India me unko exclude karna logical nahi hai. |
20 Feb 2025, 01:14 AM |
| Nivas Mohammed | Student | Kerala | 20 Feb 2025, 01:13 AM | |
| sahbaj ali | Student | West Bengal | Want to be included in defination of accountent | 20 Feb 2025, 01:12 AM |
| Vinaykumar | Student | Hyderabad | 20 Feb 2025, 01:11 AM | |
| Ayush Pandey | Student | Delhi | 20 Feb 2025, 01:10 AM | |
| Bhabani Sankar Nayak | Member | Odisha | Cost Accountant should have to be included in the Accountant definition of Income tax. | 20 Feb 2025, 01:10 AM |
| Amritam Saikia | Student | Guwahati | 20 Feb 2025, 01:09 AM | |
| MUHAMMED SHAMEER | Member | KOTTAYAM | CMA must be include in definition of 'Accountant' | 20 Feb 2025, 01:09 AM |
| CMA AKSHAT JAIN | Kolkata West bengal | I support the inclusion of CMA’ s in the definition of Accountants under section 515(3)(b) | 20 Feb 2025, 01:09 AM | |
| Pranaysingh Pardeshi | Student | Pune/ Maharashtra | To end the monopoly of CA's over tax audit & making a fair recognition of all professionals as same. | 20 Feb 2025, 01:08 AM |
| Ranajit Chowdhury | Student | Guwahati/ Assam | 20 Feb 2025, 01:08 AM | |
| Piyush Khushalani | Student | Nagpur, Maharashtra | 20 Feb 2025, 01:07 AM | |
| Kumari Shashi | Kolkata | 20 Feb 2025, 01:05 AM | ||
| AR BHUSHAN | Member | NASHIK | Respected sir , being professionals CMA must be given equal chance for Tax audits, Not only it will help govt to widen the tax audit professionals But also bring the competition, With India vision of 2047 Govt need to grip its hands on tax , which can be done with the help of tax professionals, Since CA and CMA BOTH JOIN HANDS TO RUN WELL KNOWN INSTITUTIONS LIKE PSU, BANKS, RBI, SEBI , .......ETC, THERE THEY BOTH ARE PREPARING ACCOUNTS AND PERFORMING TAX COMPLIANCES THAN WHY BIFURCATION HERE IN INCOME TAX ACT |
20 Feb 2025, 01:03 AM |
| ANIL KUMAR PANDEY | Student | Delhi | For better competitive environment there should be level playing field should be proceed to CMAs also. CMA is a vital partner in growth of Indian Economy. Therefore, his name must be included in definition of Accountant. |
20 Feb 2025, 01:03 AM |
| Mohammed unais m | Student | Kerala | Cma are competent to do tax audit | 20 Feb 2025, 01:01 AM |
| Rameshwar Chander | Student | Jammu&kashmir | The same way Ca's are eligible for ICoAS, CMA must also be included in accountants definition. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:58 AM |
| Akash kumar | Member | Jharkhand | 20 Feb 2025, 12:54 AM | |
| Aditya Pathak | Member | Nashik Maharashtra | 20 Feb 2025, 12:53 AM | |
| Owais ahmed masoodi | Student | Bangalore | 20 Feb 2025, 12:52 AM | |
| Jyoti Prasad Nayak | Member | Odisha | I Support for Inclusion of Cost Accountants in the Definition of "Accountant" in the Proposed Income Tax bill 2025 Here are the key reasons why CMAs should be included in the definition of "Accountant" in the proposed Income Tax bill 2025. 1.Equivalent taxation knowledge-: CMAs and CAs undergo the same level of taxation curriculum during their studies, covering Income Tax, GST, Transfer Pricing, and Tax Audit etc. 2.Government recognized tax work-: CMAs are already authorized to conduct GST Audits, Valuation under the Companies Act, and Special Audits under the Income Tax Act 3.Preventing monopoly & ensuring fair competition-: restricting taxation practice to only one professional body creates a monopoly, limiting taxpayer access to expert services and increasing compliance costs. 4.Contribution to Policy & Compliance-: CMAs have played a key role in GST implementation, tax planning, and compliance frameworks. Their expertise in cost management enhances tax efficiency for businesses. Excluding CMAs from the definition of "Accountant" under the Income Tax bill 2025 is not justified on competency grounds.Based on their recognized taxation expertise and contribution to tax compliance "Cost Accountants" must be included in the definition of "Accountant"to ensure fair opportunities and better tax services for businesses. |
20 Feb 2025, 12:51 AM |
| Maheswara rao | Member | Hyderabad | Cost accountants are well competent to include in Accountant definition | 20 Feb 2025, 12:50 AM |
| Suresha chandra Swain | Member | BBSR | 20 Feb 2025, 12:50 AM | |
| Dharmendra Kumar | Member | Bokaro Steel City/Jharkhand | I SUPPORT FOR PETITION TO THE PARLIAMENT FOR INCLUSION OF "COST ACCOUNTANT" IN THE DEFINITION OF "ACCOUNTANT" IN THE NEW INCOME TAX BILL-2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 12:49 AM |
| K Narayana Swamy | Member | Bangalore | CMA members have wide range of knowledge due to subjects of this course are excellent. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:43 AM |
| Mohit kumar | Student | Delhi | CMA should be considered in definition of accountant | 20 Feb 2025, 12:43 AM |
| Amir Hassan | Student | West Bengal | Respected sir/mam it's our humble request that CMA is also the part of cost and audit and we also get some chance to prove ourselves that we are also capable of such honor. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:42 AM |
| Omkar Mankame | Student | Thane | 20 Feb 2025, 12:40 AM | |
| JAYDEB BANERJEE | Member | Westbenngal | Cost Accountant should come within the defination of Accountant in income tax bill 2025. CMAs are competent to provide their knowledge in this area at per with the other professionals. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:39 AM |
| Mohd Jawwad | Student | Delhi | I strongly believe in equal opportunities for everyone. If the syllabus is uniform, then fairness demands that all individuals have the same chances. Moreover, if experts from fields like GST and Cost Audit can step into our domain, there is no justification for limiting others do support guys! |
20 Feb 2025, 12:33 AM |
| Sakshi | Solapur | 20 Feb 2025, 12:31 AM | ||
| nigar Malek | Member | Ankleswar | Yes i support the cause | 20 Feb 2025, 12:29 AM |
| Yadnesh Anant Gode | Others | Mumbai, Maharashtra | 20 Feb 2025, 12:29 AM | |
| GOPINATH | Member | CHENNAI | 20 Feb 2025, 12:27 AM | |
| Rahul shaw | Kolkata | Tax audit fot cma | 20 Feb 2025, 12:27 AM | |
| CMA SUKANTA DAS | Member | Kolkata | Cost Accountant plays vital role in the areas of management decision making | 20 Feb 2025, 12:25 AM |
| Siddhant sachan | Student | Kanpur/Uttar Pradesh | CMAs are more than competent enough to conduct Tax audit | 20 Feb 2025, 12:23 AM |
| Biswanath Mohapatra | Member | Nayagarh, Odisha | Your statement is far away from legal, constitutional and your technical education since the year 1949 where lies your scope in every Act where there is no two provision for CA and CMa. It seems to be a representation which is a trite having no benefit u/a 14 of the Constitution. Why you are not demanding such provision when CAs included in Central excise Act in the year 2010 or in second provision of sec 44AB of Income tax act followed by Gst act in the year 2016. The reason behind these is the discrimination violating article 14 and 19(1) (g) of the constion. Legal advice to get it: 1- sec 31 of ca act original making it a temporary provision awaiting Icwa act 2-The purpose of icwa for a check against human factors involved in a CA under the Evidence Act vide sec. 114 3-As Ca Act is a preconstitutional Act, it canot enter in to the field of ICWA act vide article 13(1) of the constitution4- financial accounting is primary and cost accounting is Ancilary for CA where as cost and management accounting is primary and financial accounting is primary. Full effect will be given to ancilary in a single statute having no two provisons for both as per article 14 and 19(1) (g) and also nine member bench judgment of Apex Court with one dissenting judgment in respect of ancillary education 6- As the fiscal statutes should be constued strictly, both Ca and CMA are complete accontant not being the fact that the term financial accounting is always referred to the accounting and the person is accountant. So, it is not a strict construction and tax audit for CA is compensation for audit of accounts of political parties and companies to hide prper sale after break even point. If there is no reconciliation statement, there is no requirement of income tax audit because citizens are competent to file the figures in return. This reconciliation statement influences citizens decision making under article 19(a) of the Constitution whether to retain share or dispose. So, reconciliation statement followed by the cah flow statemrnt is a check against chartered accountant by a cost accountant for the authentication of audited profit and loss accountant and balance sheet. 8- straight jacket principle of accountant can not be maintained for which check at joints should be there. 9- you can see one type of balance sheet and profit and loss account for production, processin etc in text book of financial accounting and another set of profit and account and balance sheet in the text book of cost accounting. What does it mean constitutional application? This is the geographical location of accountants. One for trading and financial concerns I. E. CA and another for production, processing, services etc concerns I. E. CMA. So supreme Court deemed to be golden rule of Apex Court. Refer also AIR 1958 SC 538 for the inefficiency promoting black money, loss to share holders clauses of enquiry in spite of financial audit and also the golden rule of article 14 including geographical location |
20 Feb 2025, 12:23 AM |
| Vikas Verma | Others | Ahmedabad | 20 Feb 2025, 12:22 AM | |
| Subhm Kumar Chourasia | Student | Asansol | 20 Feb 2025, 12:22 AM | |
| Digvijay Singh | Student | Paschim Bardhaman | inclusion of *Cost Accountants* in the Definition of " *Accountants* " as outlined in the Section 515(3)(b) under the proposed Income Tax | 20 Feb 2025, 12:21 AM |
| Archana Basu | Others | Kolkata | Cost accountant must be included in the definition of Accountant in the new income tax act 2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 12:21 AM |
| RIZWAN AHMAD | Member | GAYA | 20 Feb 2025, 12:21 AM | |
| Akhil Amara | Student | Vijayawada | A qualified CMA has knowledge to perform a tax audit and hence CMA shall be included in the definition of Accountant in Income Tax Bill, 2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 12:21 AM |
| Taranveer Singh | Student | Mumbai Maharashtra | 20 Feb 2025, 12:20 AM | |
| Vijay Bisht | Member | Delhi | I want this to happen as this will promote more people to join the profession. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:20 AM |
| Debasish Barik | Member | Odisha | We are far better than CAs | 20 Feb 2025, 12:20 AM |
| SAURAV BASU | Member | Kolkata | Cost Accountants must be included in the definition of Accountant in the new income tax act 2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 12:18 AM |
| CMA Dr Ferojuddin M A Khan | Member | Greater Noida | Cost Accountants should be included in the definition of "Accountant" under 515(3)(b) of Proposed Income Tax Act 2025 | 20 Feb 2025, 12:16 AM |
| Mayuresh Shinde | Member | Nashik | Support for inclusion of CMA in accountant definition for income tax | 20 Feb 2025, 12:16 AM |
| SANGRAM KESHARI SAHOO | Member | Bhubaneswar | CMA SHOULD BE INCLUDED IN THE DEFINITION OF ACCOUNTANT | 20 Feb 2025, 12:16 AM |
| Rima | Others | Ahmedabad | 20 Feb 2025, 12:16 AM | |
| Krishna Kumar | Student | KANCHIPURAM | We CMA's want tax audit | 20 Feb 2025, 12:15 AM |
| Tapan Kumar Rath | Member | Jharsuguda | CMA Must be included. | 20 Feb 2025, 12:13 AM |
| Sambhavi | Student | Bokaro Steel City | CMA must be included in defination of accountant | 20 Feb 2025, 12:13 AM |
| Ipireddy jeevan kumar reddy | Member | Tirupati/andhra pradesh | Any thing in the hands of single person or entity may become monopoly and there is large scope of mall practice , cost accountant nowhere less than chartered account , should include in the accountant definition | 20 Feb 2025, 12:13 AM |
| Teetu | Student | New delhi | Yes !!! i support the cause | 20 Feb 2025, 12:12 AM |